"Evan Jay Newman matches the original Valli note for note and does so in spectacular fashion."
-Bill Kellert, Nippertown
"Newman's voice and moves ring true, and you won't be disappointed in Valli's tender 'Can't Take My Eyes Off You.'" - Paul Lamar, The Daily Gazette
"Evan Jay Newman as Valli is so realistically a doppelgänger for the pop star that it is almost impossible to keep your eyes off him. He sounds so much like Valli, with an impeccable falsetto and nasal twang that one might think he is channeling the original."
-J. Peter Bergman, The Berkshire Edge
"You Believe they are The Four Seasons. This is especially true of Evan Jay Newman as Frankie Valli... Newman plays the role as an intense, honorable man who was modest about his talent. He captures those qualities even as he becomes the lead man, vocally and morally."
-Bob Goepfert, The Record